The Smart Person's Trap: Why Does Vitalik Want Us to Stick to "Dumb Rules"?
Original Author: Zhixiong Pan, Co-founder of ChainFeeds
Vitalik's article "Galaxy Brain Resistance," published a few weeks ago, was quite abstruse and not very well interpreted. So, I'll give it a try.
After all, since the creator of the term Vibe Coding, Karpathy, also read this article and took notes, there must be something special about it.
First, let's talk about what the title "Galaxy Brain" and "Resistance" mean. After interpreting this title, you will have a rough understanding of what this article is about.
1. The Chinese translation of Galaxy Brain is "银河大脑" (Galactic Brain), but it actually comes from an Internet meme, similar to an image where the galaxy and a brain are merged together, which you have definitely seen.
Initially, this term was certainly positive, used to praise that someone's idea is extremely ingenious, meaning smart. However, as its usage became widespread, it gradually turned into a kind of sarcasm, roughly meaning "overthinking, reasoning too far-fetched."
When Vitalik mentions Galaxy Brain here, he specifically refers to that kind of behavior where one "uses high intelligence to engage in mental gymnastics and forcibly turns illogical things into seemingly profound truths." For example:
- Clearly a massive layoff to save money, but insisting it is "contributing high-quality talent to society."
- Obviously issuing airdrop tokens for a rug pull, but claiming it is "empowering the global economy through decentralized governance."
All of these can be considered examples of "Galaxy Brain" thinking.
2. So, what does Resistance mean? This concept can easily be confusing. Using a popular saying, it can be likened to "the ability to resist being misled" or "the ability to resist being hoodwinked."
Therefore, Galaxy Brain Resistance should be Resistance to [becoming] Galaxy Brain, that is, "the ability to resist (evolving into) Galaxy Brain (nonsense)."
More precisely, it is used to describe the difficulty of a certain thinking/argumentation style being misused to "prove any conclusion you want."
So, this "resistance" can be targeted at a particular "theory," for example,
- Theory of Low Resistance: Upon a little scrutiny, it can evolve into the extremely outlandish "Galaxy Brain" logic.
- Theory of High Resistance: No matter how much you scrutinize it, it remains unchanged, making it difficult to develop into outlandish logic.
For example, Vitalik has mentioned that his ideal societal law should have a red line: only when one can clearly explain how a certain behavior harms or poses a risk to a specific victim can it be prohibited. This standard exhibits a high level of Galaxy Brain resistance because it does not accept vague reasons like "I subjectively dislike it" or "it is morally corrupting" that can be infinitely stretched or blurred.
3. In the article, Vitalik also provides many examples, even using commonly heard theories such as "longtermism" and "inevitabilism" as illustrations.
It's hard for "longtermism" to resist the erosion of Galaxy Brain thinking because its resistance is extremely low, akin to a "blank check." This is because the "future" is too distant and too vague.
- Statement with high resistance: "This tree will grow 5 meters taller in 10 years." This is verifiable and not easily fabricated.
- Statement with low resistance in "longtermism": "Even though I am about to commit an extremely unethical act now (such as eliminating a group of people or starting a war), it is for the sake of humanity living in a utopia in 500 years. Through my calculations, the future happiness is infinite, so the sacrifices now are negligible."
As you can see, as long as you stretch the timeline far enough, you can justify any present wrongdoing. Just as Vitalik said, "If your argument can prove anything is justified, then your argument proves nothing."
However, Vitalik also acknowledges the importance of the long term; what he criticizes is "using overly vague and unverifiable long-term benefits to overshadow clear present harm."
Another critical area is "inevitabilism."
This is also a favorite self-defense technique in Silicon Valley and the tech industry.
The rhetoric goes like this: "The replacement of human jobs by AI is an inevitable part of history, even if I don't do it, someone else will. So, my radical development of AI now is not for profit but to align with the historical trend."
Where is the low resistance? It perfectly absolves individuals of responsibility. Since it is "inevitable," I don't need to be accountable for the damage I cause.
This is also a typical Galactic Brain: transforming the selfish desires of "I want to make money / I want to hold power" into "I am carrying out a historical mission."
4. So how should we deal with these "smart people's traps"?
The antidote given by Vitalik is surprisingly simple, even a bit "dumb." He believes that the smarter a person is, the more they need high-resistance rules to constrain themselves and prevent their intellectual acrobatics from going awry.
First, adhere to "Deontological Ethics," which is a kindergarten-level moral absolute.
Don't engage in complex mathematical calculations for the "future of humanity"; instead, return to the most rigid principles:
- Do not steal
- Do not kill innocent people
- Do not commit fraud
- Respect others' freedom
These rules are highly resistant because they are black and white, non-negotiable. When you try to explain why you embezzled user funds with the grand reasoning of "long-termism," the rigid rule of "do not steal" will directly confront you: theft is theft, don't talk about it being for the great financial revolution.
Second, hold the correct "position," even including physical location.
As the saying goes, where you sit determines where you stand. If you surround yourself with people involved in AI accelerationism in the echo chamber of the San Francisco Bay Area every day, it's challenging to stay sane. Vitalik even provides a high-resistance suggestion at a physical level: don't live in the San Francisco Bay Area.
5. Conclusion
This article by Vitalik is actually a warning to those extremely intelligent elites: don't think you can bypass basic moral boundaries just because you have a high IQ.
The "Galactic Brain" theories that sound like they can explain everything are often the most dangerous universal excuses. On the other hand, it is the seemingly rigid and dogmatic "high-resistance" rules that are the final line of defense against self-deception.
You may also like

Trump Says He Was Unaware of $500M UAE Investment in World Liberty Financial
Key Takeaways: US President Donald Trump denied knowledge of a $500 million UAE investment in World Liberty Financial.…

Crypto Industry and Banks at a Stalemate Over Stablecoin Yield Deal
Key Takeaways The White House has urged a compromise on stablecoin yields to progress Senate crypto legislation. Crypto…

Why Vitalik Buterin Sold Over 700 Ethereum (ETH) Despite Market Recovery
Key Takeaways Vitalik Buterin sold over 700 Ethereum not for market reasons but to finance long-term projects. The…

Binance Withdrawals Restored Following Temporary Disruption
Key Takeaways Binance faced technical difficulties affecting withdrawals, but services were quickly restored within 20 minutes. The disruption…

Asian Markets Stabilize as Bitcoin Trades Around $78K
Key Takeaways Bitcoin steadies at approximately $78,000 as Asian markets recover from recent volatility. Regional equities, including Japan’s…

Bitcoin Price Prediction: The Warsh Shock & The Stablecoin Summit—Is the Bull Case Dead?
Key Takeaways Kevin Warsh’s nomination as Federal Reserve Chair has caused a drop in liquidity for riskier assets,…

White House Continues to Negotiate Over Crypto Market Structure Bill
Key Takeaways The White House is pushing for a compromise on the contentious issue of stablecoin yields in…

Billionaire Michael Saylor’s Strategy Acquires $75M More Bitcoin – Is This a Bullish Sign?
Key Takeaways Michael Saylor’s Strategy has expanded its Bitcoin holdings by purchasing an additional 855 BTC for $75.3…

Polymarket Bettors Assign Over 70% Probability of Bitcoin Dropping Below $65K — Are They Correct?
Key Takeaways Polymarket users predict Bitcoin has a 71% chance of falling below $65,000 in 2026, reflecting market…

CFTC Regulatory Shift Could Unlock New Growth for Coinbase Prediction Markets
Key Takeaways Newly appointed CFTC Chair, Michael Selig, aims for a unified federal oversight approach for crypto-linked prediction…

We Hacked Perplexity AI to Predict the Price of XRP, Bitcoin, and Ethereum By the End of 2026
Key Takeaways Perplexity AI predicts XRP may soar to $8 by 2026, fueled by legal victories and supportive…

Current Crypto Price Predictions: An In-Depth Analysis of XRP, Dogecoin, and Shiba Inu
Key Takeaways XRP, Dogecoin, and Shiba Inu are experiencing significant price declines amid geopolitical uncertainties and general market…

Pepe Coin Forecast: Price Appears Dismal, Yet Savvy Investors Rally Behind the Scenes
Key Takeaways Pepe Coin has experienced significant price drops, yet indicators suggest it may soon bottom out, with…

BitMine Reports 4.285M ETH Holdings, Expands Staked Position With Massive Reward Outlook
Key Takeaways BitMine Immersion Technologies has reported significant crypto holdings valued at $10.7 billion. The company’s Ethereum holdings…

Crypto Exchanges’ Stock Plunge 60% as Trading Volumes Dwindle – Is the Decline Ending or Just Beginning?
Key Takeaways Trading volumes on major crypto exchanges have drastically fallen, with a nearly 90% drop from October…

Best Crypto to Acquire Now February 2 – XRP, Solana, Ethereum
Key Takeaways Recent market turmoil saw Bitcoin plunge dramatically, affecting all major cryptocurrencies. XRP, Solana, and Ethereum are…

Ethereum Price Prediction: Top ETH Bulls Face $7.6 Billion in Paper Losses as Price Drops Below $2,400
Key Takeaways Ethereum has faced a downturn, dropping 19% below $2,400, resulting in significant paper losses for major…

Shiba Inu Price Prediction: SHIB Just Crashed to a 3-Year Low – Is SHIB Heading Towards Zero?
Key Takeaways Shiba Inu has recently hit a significant low, experiencing a 15% drop that places it at…
Trump Says He Was Unaware of $500M UAE Investment in World Liberty Financial
Key Takeaways: US President Donald Trump denied knowledge of a $500 million UAE investment in World Liberty Financial.…
Crypto Industry and Banks at a Stalemate Over Stablecoin Yield Deal
Key Takeaways The White House has urged a compromise on stablecoin yields to progress Senate crypto legislation. Crypto…
Why Vitalik Buterin Sold Over 700 Ethereum (ETH) Despite Market Recovery
Key Takeaways Vitalik Buterin sold over 700 Ethereum not for market reasons but to finance long-term projects. The…
Binance Withdrawals Restored Following Temporary Disruption
Key Takeaways Binance faced technical difficulties affecting withdrawals, but services were quickly restored within 20 minutes. The disruption…
Asian Markets Stabilize as Bitcoin Trades Around $78K
Key Takeaways Bitcoin steadies at approximately $78,000 as Asian markets recover from recent volatility. Regional equities, including Japan’s…
Bitcoin Price Prediction: The Warsh Shock & The Stablecoin Summit—Is the Bull Case Dead?
Key Takeaways Kevin Warsh’s nomination as Federal Reserve Chair has caused a drop in liquidity for riskier assets,…