USDT Insolvent? Arthur Hayes Publicly Questions Tether

Original Title: "Arthur Hayes Warns of USDT Insolvency Risk, Why the Recent FUD Frenzy?"

Original Author: Azuma,  Odaily Star Daily

Following a public feud with Monad, "Big Brother" Arthur Hayes has once again unexpectedly clashed with the stablecoin king Tether.

Arthur Hayes: USDT May Face "Insolvency" Risk

The incident originated on November 30th when Arthur Hayes posted on X regarding Tether's publicly disclosed third-quarter reserves at the end of October. He analyzed that Tether's allocation of volatile assets such as gold and Bitcoin in its reserve assets is too high. USDT may face an "insolvency" risk due to the decline of these assets.

"The Tether team is in the early stages of a massive interest rate trade. Based on my understanding of their audit report, they believe the Fed will start cutting rates, which will significantly compress their interest income. In response, they started buying gold and Bitcoin—ideally, when the 'currency price falls' (rate cut), these assets should rise. But if their gold + Bitcoin position drops by about 30%, Tether's equity will be wiped out, and USDT theoretically will face insolvency."

As shown in the above chart, out of a total of $181.223 billion in Tether's reserve assets, there is a $12.921 billion reserve of precious metals (7.1% share) and a $9.856 billion reserve of Bitcoin (5.4% share)—the combined share of these two assets reaches 12.5% of Tether's total reserve assets.

From Tether's reserve structure, it can be seen that Arthur Hayes may have objectively pointed out a potential extreme scenario that Tether may face. If the gold and Bitcoin reserves simultaneously experience a significant devaluation, theoretically, the value of Tether's reserve assets will not be able to fully cover the issuance scale of USDT.

This point was also mentioned by the well-known rating agency Standard & Poor's last week when downgrading Tether's and USDT's stability ratings, stating "Tether's Bitcoin reserve value accounts for approximately 5.6% of the total USDT circulation volume (Odaily Note: Standard & Poor's here is comparing circulation volume, so the percentage data will be slightly higher than when compared to reserves), exceeding USDT's own 3.9% excess collateralization rate. This means that other low-risk reserve assets (mainly government bonds) are no longer able to fully support the value of USDT. If BTC and other high-risk assets decline in value, it may weaken the coverage ability of USDT's reserves, leading to under-collateralization of USDT."

Is USDT Still Safe?

Arthur Hayes actually described the same situation as Standard & Poor's, but the likelihood of this situation actually occurring is very minimal, for two specific reasons.

· Firstly, it is hard to imagine an instantaneous sharp drop in the price of gold and Bitcoin (referring to a drop of at least several tens of points in a very short period), even in a scenario of sustained decline, Tether theoretically has time to replenish its reserve of low-risk assets by selling.

· Secondly, besides its reserve assets, Tether itself holds a huge amount of proprietary assets, which are sufficient as a reserve buffer pool for USDT to sustain the operation of this cash flow machine.

Joseph, former Cryptocurrency Research Head at Citigroup, also mentioned the second point, stating that the assets disclosed by Tether do not represent all of its holdings—when Tether generates profits, they have a separate equity balance sheet that is not publicly disclosed together with the reserve situation; Tether has an extremely strong profitability, and the value of its equity is very high, allowing them to offset any gaps on the balance sheet by selling equity; Tether will not go bankrupt; on the contrary, they have a money-printing machine.

Tether's Response

Yesterday evening, as FUD related to this matter escalated, Tether's CEO Paolo Ardoino responded in a post, stating that as of the end of the third quarter of 2025, Tether holds approximately $70 billion in excess equity (beyond the approximately $184.5 billion stablecoin reserves), along with an additional approximately $23 billion in retained earnings, together constituting Tether Group's proprietary equity.

A clear comparison of assets and liabilities:

· Total assets of the Tether Group: approximately $215 billion;

· Stablecoin liabilities: approximately $184.5 billion;

Standard & Poor's also made the same mistake, failing to account for these additional group equities, and not considering the approximately $500 million in basic monthly profits generated solely from U.S. Treasury bond returns.

Interestingly, Paolo Ardoino concluded with a special note: "Some internet celebrities either have poor math skills or impure motives."

· Odaily Note: Arthur Hayes and his family office investment firm Maelstrom are key investors in the interest-bearing stablecoin Ethena (USDe), and have repeatedly predicted that USDe will become the largest stablecoin by issuance volume.

After Paolo Ardoino responded directly, Arthur Hayes also replied again, but his remarks were somewhat sarcastic: "You guys are making so much money, I'm so jealous. Do you have a specific dividend policy? Or a target overcollateralization rate based on asset type (discounted by its volatility)? Obviously, when your liability is in dollars and your asset is U.S. Treasuries, there is no problem, but if your asset is illiquid private investments, in case of an accident, people may question your claim of being overcollateralized."

After this exchange, neither party continued to reply. Arthur Hayes did post a dynamic this morning, but it was just about calling a bounce in the market.

From the photos shared by Arthur Hayes, after ranting about Monad and Tether in succession, his mood seemed quite good...

Original Article Link

This content is provided for general informational purposes only and doesn't constitute financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Any events, rewards, online promotions, or related information mentioned herein should not be considered a recommendation, solicitation, or invitation to purchase, sell, trade, or otherwise deal in any crypto assets. Crypto assets are highly volatile and may result in loss. The availability of WEEX services, products, and related events may vary by region. You are responsible for ensuring that your participation is in accordance with applicable local laws and regulations.